Guest Stars Anna Torv as Olivia Dunham (Alt Universe) John Noble as Dr. Walter Bishop (Alt Universe) Jasika Nicole as Astrid Farnsworth (Alt Universe) Seth Gabel as Lincoln Lee (Alt Universe) Lance Reddick as Colonel Phillip Broyles (Alt Universe) Kirk Acevedo as Charlie Francis (Alt Universe) Andre Royo as Henry Arliss Higgins Curtis Harris as Christopher Broyles Michael Strusievici as Max Clayton Will Rothhaar as Wyatt Toomy Co Starring Karen Holness as Diane Broyles (Alt Universe) David Nykl as Reverend Marcus Tristen Leffler as Emily Clayton Elizabeth McCarthy as Cleaning Lady Barry Nerling as Head MP Lawrence Haegert as Harold Jason Diablo as Detective John Hainsworth as Old Wyatt Toomy Uncredited Michael Cerveris as September