Guest Stars Jennifer Jason Leigh as Jill Price-Gray Michael Harney as Det. Mitch Ouellette Gavin Kent as Stevie Ethan Kent as Stevie Amanda Pace as Taylor Danièle Watts as Angela Mullen David Julian Hirsh as Rabbi David Bloom Rachel Pace as Shayla Ben Tolpin as Zachary Craig Anton as Mark Powell Aaron Zachary Philips as Jonah Max Barakat as Matthew Rebecca Metz as Gina Tim Guinee as Dr. Dan Cornish Jackie Geary as Deb Cindy Drummond as Mitzi Megan Grano as Preggo Larissa Laskin as Elizabeth Kash Simbi Khali as Mary Ronnie Rose Jr. as Rico Diane Kelber as Dr. Galante Catherine Lidstone as Kendra Shaun Daley as Tom Co Starring Joe Ochman as Auctioneer Gabriel Aslan as Jewish Student Kevin Fabian as Auction Guy Michelle Glavan as Hostess