Guest Stars Guillermo Diaz as Guillermo Maulik Pancholy as Sanjay Shoshannah Stern as Megan Graves Michael Harney as Det. Mitch Ouellette Bruce Nozick as Whit Tillerman Fatso Fasano as Marvin Daryl Sabara as Tim Scottson Julanne Chidi Hill as clinique Allyn Rachel as Monica Nancy Youngblut as Beatrice Justin Chatwin as Josh Wilson Patch Darragh as Crick Montgomery Mateus Ward as Stevie Jake Sandvig as Alan Spiller Laura Harrison as Cinnamon Ryann Turner as Sage Natasha Lyonne as Tiffany Kathleen Gati as Olga Catherine Chan as China Rabbi Mark Sob El as Rabbi Co Starring Lesley Wolff as China's Mom #1 Colby French as Father Three Paula Sorge as China's Mom #2 Dorian Frankel as Cantor Larry Dorf as Father One Tom G. McMahon as Father Two