Special Guest Stars John Lithgow as Arthur Mitchell Guest Stars Courtney Ford as Christine Hill Brando Eaton as Jonah Mitchell Mary Mara as Valerie Hodges Jake Short as Scott Smith Co Starring Preston Bailey as Cody Bennett Roger Ranney as Nick Smith Kavita Patil as Doctor J.R. Cacia as Officer Gordon Mike Kersey as Volunteer Kathy Christopherson as Jill Sarah Grant Brendecke as Nanny Katie Grant as Woman