Guest Stars Mike Colter as Lemond Bishop Sarah Steele as Marissa Gold Steven Pasquale as Jonathan Elfman David Fonteno as Judge Robert Parks Dylan Baker as Colin Sweeney Eric Ruffin as Dylan Bishop David Krumholtz as Josh Mariner David Hyde Pierce as Frank Prady Laura Benanti as Renata Ellard-Sweeney Edward Asner as Guy Redmayne Andrew Dolan as Det. Rick Crowell Elise Rooker as Crystal Redmayne Julie White as Selma Krause Dylan Baker as Jerome Morris Bill English as Greg Tierney Tara Westwood as Woman Anthony Amorim as Mike Zeiler Annalaina Marks as Debbie Conlon