Guest Stars Michael James Shaw as Papa Midnite Emmett J. Scanlan as Jim Corrigan Annalise Basso as Vesta Whitney J.D. Evermore as The Man Julie Ivey as Anna Kate Whitney Co Starring Cassady McClincy as Amberly Madison Bailey as Caroline Zach Hanner as Guard Thom Scott II as Dwayne Jed Sloe as Homeless Man Zamani Wilder as Waynetta Uncredited Jonjo O'Neill voices Gary Lester