Guest Stars Malcolm Barrett as FJ Hoover Tyson Ritter as Humperdoo Ronald Guttman as Denis Tyson Ritter as Jesus Christ Tom Thon as The Pope Carrie Lazar as Messiah Mother David St. James as Archibishop of Canterbury Co Starring Felipe Fuentes as Durando Jordan Salloum as Bartender Peggy Walton-Walker as Grail Midwife Breanna B. Turner as September Douglas Schneider as Grail Recruit #2 Chip Carriere as Grail Recruit #1 Dean West as Thaddeus Finch Nissen as John the Apostle