Guest Stars Retta as Donna Meagle Jim O'Heir as Jerry Gergich Jama Williamson as Wendy Haverford Phil Reeves as Paul Iaresco Justin Theroux as Justin Anderson Don McManus as Randall Gary Weeks as Nick Newport Jr. Co Starring Blake Lee as Derek Josh Duvendeck as Ben Sara Van Horn as Gretel Brooke Baumer as Marci Christopher Murray as Nick Newport Sr. Jeffrey Markle as Man 2 Brendan Hunt as Man 3 Harley Graham as Dakota Michael O'Hare as Waiter David Hadinger as Man 1 Ryan Hartwig as Denver