Guest Stars Jama Williamson as Wendy Haverford Megan Mullally as Tammy Swanson Will McLaughlin as Officer Randy Killnose Eric Pierpoint as Chief Trumple Brooke Baumer as Marci Kurt Scholler as Police Officer #3 Marc Raducci as Police Officer #4 James Sharpe as Jack Tracy Howe as Police Officer #1 Craig Pearman as Justice Of The Peace Matt Kelley as Waiter