Guest Stars Janet Varney as Becca Barbara Colin Ferguson as Boone Anne Dudek as Whitney Brendan Jennings as Neil Jessica Stroup as Young Faye Lucy Montgomery as Katherine Robin Riker as Fay Cottumaccio Lou Diamond Phillips as Himself Emily Althaus as Mariel Craig Frank as Charlie Whitmer Thomas as Flynn Co Starring Kevin Young as Waiter Emily Hinkler as Female PA Devyn Rush as Scream Singer