Guest Stars Randy Flagler as Firefighter Harold Capp Robyn Coffin as Cindy Herrmann Melissa Ponzio as Donna Boden Marina Squerciati as Officer Kim Burgess Yaya DaCosta as Nurse April Sexton Gordon Clapp as Chaplain Orlovsky Brian Geraghty as Sean Roman Warren Christie as Firefighter Scott Rice Alexandra Metz as Elise Mills Co Starring Anthony Ferraris as Squad 3 Driver Tony Ferraris Lucas VonKampen as Luke Herrmann David VonKampen as Lee Henry Herrmann Amanda Calabrese as Annabelle Herrmann Logan Vosburgh as Max Herrmann Samuel Taylor as Ed Slater Francisco Posada as Gearhead Bud Wheeler as April's Father Bob Thorson as Mr. Alexander Melissa Galvin as Jenna Jamie Campbell as Bartender Michael Pogue as Surgeon Paula Anglin as April's Mother Jonathan Chronos as Driver Erica Faye Watson as Waitress Uncredited Anne Lockhart voices Dispatcher John William Adams III as Kenny James Herrmann