Guest Stars Sammi Hanratty as Dollie Trask Azure Parsons as Gloriana Stephen Lang as Increase Mather Co Starring Lara Grice as Mrs. Hale Morgana Shaw as Mab Mary Katherine O'Donnell as Emily Benjamin Mouton as Lamb Rachel Whitman Groves as Mrs. Trask Sharon Landry as Mrs. Barker Colby Boothman as Boatswain Melanie Haynes as Neighbor #2 Stephanie Morgan as Neighbor #1 Timothy McKinney as Neighbor #3 David Jensen as Captain Daniel James as Joseph Barker