Guest Stars Nestor Carbonell as Sheriff Alex Romero Keegan Connor Tracy as Miss Watson Mike Vogel as Deputy Zack Shelby Brittney Wilson as Lissa Jenna Romanin as Jenna Richard Harmon as Richard Sylmore David Cubitt as Sam Bates Emmalyn Estrada as Hayden Conchita Campbell as Kennedy W. Earl Brown as Keith Summers Co Starring Stephen Boersma as Dude #1