Guest Stars Valerie Cruz as Agent Gina Mendez Sprague Grayden as Carrie Cooke Camille de Pazzis as Giselle Susan Heyward as Hannah Carrie Preston as Judy J.D. Williams as Carlos Perez Keith Carradine as Barry James McDaniel as Agent Ken Phillips C.J. Wilson as Reverend Glen Davis James McCaffrey as David Roland Co Starring Josephine Huang as Kimmy Natalie Roy as Alice Pete Postiglione as Carl Juan-Pablo Veza as Suited Man #3 Chad Gittens as Suited Man #2 Dion Mucciacito as Suited Man #1 Mason Schneiderman as Ben Addison Lemay as NYPD Officer #1