Guest Stars Gregg Henry as Dr. Arthur Strauss John Lafayette as Deputy Marshal Scott Turner Sprague Grayden as Carrie Cooke Shane McRae as Robert Felix Solis as Agent Jeffrey Clarke Mackenzie Marsh as Tilda Josh Salatin as Lucas Aaron Lazar as Billy Boyer Emily Kinney as Mallory Hodge Theo Stockman as Patrick Trano Pico Alexander as Young Joe Co Starring Kristina Klebe as Carla Brynn Alexander as Hostess Billy Marshall Jr. as Matthew Blair Sams as Kate Laura Sametz as Valerie Mark Morettini as John Faith Sandberg as IT Agent