Guest Stars Corinne Massiah as Lucy Malloy Justin Hartley as Scott Trosman Dondre T. Whitfield as Paul Malloy Jason Gray-Stanford as FBI Agent Adam Thomas Ricky Whittle as Daniel Zamora Helena Mattsson as Greta Jager Lee Garlington as Eleanor Jason Gerhardt as Zack Kilmer Brian Hallisay as Ben Mary Pat Gleason as Debbie Tim Fields as band leader Gigi Bermingham as intake nurse Al Coronel as FBI Agent Neto DePaula Pimenta as Rafi Anthony Holiday as agent Gordon Monique Lea as Ella Austin Brooks as Agent Harris Bill Blair as priest