Guest Stars Kayli Carter as Sadie Rose Samantha Soule as Charlotte Temple Audrey Moore as Sarah Doyle Samuel Marty as Truckee Adam David Thompson as Gatz Brown Joe Pingue as Alonzo Bunker Matthew Dennis Lewis as Donnie Devlin Justin Welborn as Floyd Wilson Travis Hammer as John Doe Luke Robertson as Bill Chick Rio Alexander as Bud Ledbetter Keith Jardine as Dyer Howe Tess Frazer as Callie Dunne Russell Dennis Lewis as Daryl Devlin Marie Wagenman as Trudy McNue Jeremy Bobb as A.T. Grigg Christiane Seidel as Martha Randy Oglesby as Asa Leopold Brian Lee Franklin as Amos Green Julian Grey as William McNue Russell G. Jones as Hiram Duane Howard as Shoshone Brave Jessica Sula as Louise Hobbs Eric LaRay Harvey as Elias Rob Morgan as John Randall Elisa Perry as June Hobbs Matthew Puett as Daile Review Apprentice Mathew Greer as Grandfather Damon Sarah Minnich as Nicholas' Wife Christopher Fitzgerald as J.J. Valentine John Wylie as Colonel Farnsworth Shawn-Caulin Young as Jacob Gustavson Trine Christensen as Jacob's Wife Gene Jones as Elton Cunningham Ali Agirnas as Nicholas Gustavson Colin Miller as Nathan the Telegram Boy Adam Taylor as Olagrande Barkeep