Guest Stars Tracie Thoms as FBI Agent Maya Kennedy Kelly Rutherford as Paula Lannigan Lee Tergesen as Mel Foster Christopher O'Shea as Noah Sager Jordan Bridges as Neil Pruitt Tracy Middendorf as Sr. Helen Ross Rosa Arredondo as FBI Deputy Director Moss Marcia DeBonis as Prison Social Worker Co Starring Danica Ketcham as Beth Foster Chloi Zi as Cassie Breann Couch as TBD Cindy Jackson as EMT Joseph Meissner as Tattooed Inmate Keith Flippen as Michael Sager Selena Anduze as Vivian Mike Lee as TBD Jessica Albert as TBD Gianna Desch as Six-year-old Kick Jerry Lee Tucker as Pittsburgh Police Officer Ron Jenkins as TBD Patti Davidson-Gorbea as TBD