Guest Stars Rex Linn as Nathan Riggs Kristen Gutoskie as Molly Hendricks Andrew Patrick Ralston as Jim McNeile Martin Donovan as Grant Davenport Chelsea Tavares as Crystal Juan Riedinger as Liam Taylor Eddie Ramos as Diego Cabrera Co Starring Duncan Joiner as Ben Hendricks Mavrick Moreno as Robbie McNeile Chuck McCollum as Arthur Efka Kvaraciejus as Thug #2 Todd Anthony as Uni Ian Stanley as Cop Erin McIntosh as Costumed Elf Jim Palmer as South Pole Bartender Toby Wilson as Bouncer Jesse La Flair as Jasper Justin A. Williams as Thug #1