Special Guest Stars Scott Glenn as Alan Pangborn Guest Stars Caleel Harris as Young Henry Deaver Adam Rothenberg as Reverend Matthew Deaver Jeffrey Pierce as Young Alan Pangborn Chosen Jacobs as Wendell Deaver Zabryna Guevara as Dr. Vargas Schuyler Fisk as Young Ruth Deaver Co Starring Billy Thorpe as Party Guest #1 Andrea Higgins as Funeral Goer Caroline Lawton as Deputy Fran Dayshaun Moore as Young Henry Deaver (Age 7) Charlotte Peed as Party Guest #2 Paul Meredith as Utility Truck Driver