Guest Stars Aubrey Plaza as Lindsay Timothy Simons as Chris Whitman Jennifer Kim as Annie Joe Lo Truglio as Mike Lawrence Michael Levine as Harrison Atkins Co Starring Stephanie Diaz as Teenager #2's Mom Abe Kanan voices Himself (Abe the Chameleon) Elijah Ruiz as Teenager #1 John Cayo as Firefighter #3 Matthew Kramer as Whitman and Annie's Son Hayley Alexander as Four Square Kid #1 Joseph Alexander as Four Square Kid #2 Ella June Wilke as Four Square Kid #3 Stacy Trulley as Stacy the Neighbor Tom Maldonado as Package Thief Stephen Bialas as Sandbox Kid #2 Alvaro Padilla as Teenager #2 Nick Vergis as Police Officer #2 Cathy Vlahogiannis voices Herself (Cathy the Greek) Ted Kramer as Firefighter #1 Tyler J. Sokolowski as Sandbox Kid #4 Dane Bialas as Sandbox Kid #3 Layla Vidmar as Sandbox Kid #1 Maura Conine as Sandbox Kid Mom Juan Sotomayor as Firefighter #2 Cynthia Brown as Police Officer #1 Ken Smith voices Himself (Al Roker Jr) Charin Alvarez as Teenager #1's Mom Erich Muller voices Himself (The Mancow) Joseph Luis Caballero as Teenager #2's Dad Uncredited Gugu Mbatha-Raw as Coach Kendall