Guest Stars Amy Rhodes as Judy Rob Riggle as Chet Alex Wyse as Bobby T.C. Carson as Judge Marcus Pitt Co Starring Kim Gatewood as Kiki Omar Leyva as Bar Patron Elaine Loh as Female Juror #2 Shannon McClung as Defense Attorney Chris Erric Maddox as Male Juror #2 Ryan Lockett II as Angry Guy Ted Cannon as Male Juror #1 Roman Santa Croce as Eduardo Erin Callahan as Female Juror #1 Uncredited Chris Sundlee as Lawyer