Guest Stars James Ransone as Michael O'Connor Don Hudson as Reporter Christopher Robin Miler as Reporter Hillary Straga as Reporter Talese Hunt as Reporter Dan Pope as Reporter Jenny Kay Provence as Reporter Allison Tolman as Amy Lambson Joseph Skousen as Petra's Assistant Brandon Ray Olive as Dick Andreesen Pascoalina Dunham as Graciella Anne Sward as Elizabeth Neill Ben Livingston as B. David Stocker James DuMont as Taylor and Ava's Dad Aaron Vexler as Joel's Opponent Clint Vanderlinden as Manager Russell Easley as Bobby Sinclair Dumont as Ava Ashley E. Parker as Waitress Nancy Odenbrett as Courthouse Clerk Jeffrey Hanson as Surveyor James Couts as Surveyor Marty Steinberg as Judge Stevens Kelton DuMont as Taylor