Guest Stars Stephanie Szostak as Annabelle Harper Maryann Plunkett as Judge Donna Daniel London as Mark Zimmer C.J. Wilson as Dr. Donovan Benanti Samuel H. Levine as Lex Booker Steve Mack as Thomas Milton Thomas Place as Brady Harper Co Starring Amanda Dela Cruz as Juror #7 Miller Tai as Juror #12 Ryan J. Haddad as Juror #2 Naaji Kenn as Administrative Assistant