Guest Stars Demore Barnes as Wayne Martin Camryn Manheim as Balenda Thibodeau Annika Marks as Kathy Schroeder Stephanie Kurtzuba as Carol Noesner Andy Umberger as Perry Jones Eli Goodman as Barry Skinner Christopher Stanley as Edward Wiggins Steven Culp as Peter Hardwick Sarah Minnich as Angela Duke Co Starring Vivien Lyra Blair as Serenity Jones Duncan Joiner as Cyrus J.B. Tuttle as Davey Jones Tait Fletcher as Brad Branch Cayen Martin as Jamie Martin Darcel Danielle as Sheila Martin Ryan Jason Cook as Derek Ludlow Kenneth Miller as Mike Schroeder Kimberly Bigsby as Jaydean Wendell Kimberly Kiegel as Catherine Matteson Matthew Page as Nate Madrono Jack O'Donnell as OPR Agent