Guest Stars Deirdre O'Connell as Gaby Aimée Laurence as Summer Lane Adriane Lenox as Felicia Pickard Keir Dullea as Dr. Steven Meyer Sarita Choudhury as Lilith Asan Titus Makin, Jr. as Caleb Matthews Vincent Kartheiser as Congressman Buck Harbaugh Co Starring Monica Wyche as Rita Laslen Amy Lynn Sheehan as Monica Christopher Kelly as Young Steve Kevyn Morrow as Reverend William Matthews Philip Hernández as Doctor Costa Michele McNally as Sharon Walker Jo Lampert as Jeremy Dena Tyler as Claudia Darlene Dues as Paula Susannah Schulman Rogers as Linda Locke Caryn Esch as Cassie Connie Esch as Kasey JD Goldsmith as JD Samantha Hirschel as Sam David Licht as Faithful Husband Gina Siani as Young Felicia Nancy Fox as Faithful Wife Eric J. Carlson as Eric Michael Lewis as Mike