Guest Stars Sydney Sweeney as Emaline Addario Rio Mangini as McQuaid Zachary Ray Sherman as Leroy O'Neil Co Starring Abi Brittle as Leslie Nicole McCullough as Jessica Betts Ben York Jones as Mr. Stargrove Connor Muhl as Scott Pocket Kiah Butts as Punky Friend Sunday Manisto-Saari as Punky Friend 2 / Musical Theatre Geek Anjini Azhar as Lindsay Audrey Boos as Olivia