Guest Stars Paul Guilfoyle as Henry Rindell Bernadette Peters as Lenore Rindell Heléne Yorke as Amy Breslin Denis O'Hare as Judge Charles Abernathy Kristen Carpenter as Rosalie Richetta Sam McMurray as Joe Swoboda Caroline Aaron as Lucy Heinberg Tess Soltau as Sonya Samantha Massell as Esther Lance Williams as Unnamed Person Co Starring Mark Jacoby as News Panel Commentator Jed Orlemann as Tim Shefflin Gabriel Lawrence as News Panel Prosecutor