Guest Stars Aparna Brielle as Sarika Sarkar Nick Peine as Marcus Kasperak Paula Pell as Helen Henry Demarcus Jacob McCarthy as Devin Lori Alan as Didi Kasperak Erinn Hayes as Trish McConnell Anjali Bhimani as Sarika's Mom Lisa Loeb as Herself Co Starring Allisyn Ashley Arm as Heather Willmore Jacob Houston as Victor Kozlowski Eddie Leavy as Anthony Lewis Sari Arambulo as Grace Spence Moore II as Dan Decker Charlie McCrackin as Coach Dick Novak Tucker Albrizzi as Colin McConnell Dominique Morton as Angry Student Hans Holsen as Ron Willmore Rebecca Sohn as Prude Mom