Guest Stars Alton Fitzgerald White as Judge Tahani Kevin Corrigan as Rick Brown Jeremy Davidson as ADA Peluso Nathan Darrow as Jim Grayson Celia Keenan-Bolger as Kristen Grayson Ed Moran as Officer Lyden Juan Castano as Young Rick Brown Paul Skye Lehrman as Young George Brown Co Starring James Gunn as Uniformed Officer Brian Sgambati as Plain Clothes Detective James A. Stephens as Juror #11 Steve Sanpietro as Det. Mayovsky Carla Oudin as Malone Grayson Kim Bonifay as Juror #1