Guest Stars Bebe Neuwirth as Judge Claudia Friend Greta Lee as Amber Wood-Lutz Glenn Stott as Dennis Honeycutt Kevin McNally as Franz Mendelssohn Matt Walsh as Judge Oliver Walenstadt Evan Handler as Jonathan Arnie Burton as Chuck Connie Ray as Mrs. Honeycutt Darren Ritchie as Moderator Cardigan John Schiappa as Warren Hesseman Maurice Jones as Jedidiah Wayne Wilcox as Dale Kuzma Co Starring Meredith Garretson as Reese Q Smith as Make-Up Artist José Ramón Rosario as Harriss (Sheriff) Julia Atwood as Lacey Harmon Markita Prescott as Anya