Guest Stars Mahershala Ali as Nathan Cley Erin Way as Kat Steve Byers as John Bennett Morgan Kelly as Tommy Co Starring Katie Douglas as Teenage Nina Robert B. Kennedy as Robert Lewis Sarah Manninen as Becky Michael Dyson as Cashier Daniel Park as Cop Rod Wilson as Nina's Dad Arlene Mazerolle as Nina's Mom Jack Ilijanich as Lucas Natalia Ross as Hot Girl Sava Drayton as Security Guard Rian Michelsen as Teenage Tommy Lenno Britos as Pushed Man