Guest Stars Tonya Glanz as Jessica Karen David as Young Denise Christopher Pooja Batra as Ananya Sirivastava Matthew Alan as Owen Madoff Erik Stocklin as John Hinckley Jr. Co Starring Marci T. House as Michelle McKenna Roberts as Olivia Christopher Chuck McCollum as Lieutenant Green Andrew Pifko as Young Rudy Guliani Edith Fields as Elderly Woman Michael Garza as Mark Christopher Sathya Jesudasson as Puja Devati Vishal Patel as Sunil Devati Clint Culp as Officer Thomas Delahanty Jefferson Black as President Ronald Reagan Uncredited Bryan Friday as SS Agent Jerry Parr Bryan Dodds as Zach