Guest Stars Jerry Lambert as Principal Michael Ablin Carly Craig as Tara Summers Julie Meyer as Maria Jessica St. Clair as Chloe Brown Mueller Jeannette Sousa as Suzanne Sara Rue as Nancy Granville Ravi Patel as Grant Kathleen Rose Perkins as Stacy Clouser Nathan Fillion as Himself Co Starring Kevin Held as Male Party Guest Mike Still as Farmer Alison Whitney as Female Party Guest #2 Maria Pallas as Female Party Guest #1