Guest Stars Curtis Lum as Calvin David Cubitt as Ted Pownall Sarah Jane Redmond as Elaine Pownall Sedale Threatt Jr. as Levi Aylya Marzolf as Katrina Chad Rook as Chris Mueller Andrew Jenkins as Doug Pownall Jill Teed as Widow McClure Co Starring Hannah Levien as Janine Tammy Gillis as Deputy Marissa Staub Brad Kelly as Wally J. Douglas Stewart as Randy Shayne Elliott as Rick Angela Moore as Town Pastor Janet Glassford as Community Woman #1 Kasey Kieler as Man on Boat Shauna Hansen as Crying Woman Joe Costa as Rough Fisherman #2 Gail Hamilton as Community Woman #2