Guest Stars Tyler Jacob Moore as Pastor John Tudor Eric Winter as Luke Lourd Lauran Irion as Laura Vaughn Hartley Sawyer as Bozeman Peacham Bruce Boxleitner as Burl Lourd Mackinlee Waddell as McKinney Peacham Co Starring Erin Alexis as Sapphire Alix Elizabeth Gitter as Alexandra Reilly Jack DePew as Landry Cockburn Matt Lowe as Rowdy Guy Jorge Diaz as Paramedic Selah Victor as Female Parishioner Allison Weintraub as Emma Green