Special Guest Stars Gil Birmingham as Sheriff Bishop Guest Stars Curtis Lum as Calvin David Cubitt as Ted Pownall Sedale Threatt Jr. as Levi Aylya Marzolf as Katrina Natalee Linez as Nicole Martinez Garcelle Beauvais as Susan Bishop Patrick Gallagher as Dr. Abbott Co Starring Hannah Levien as Janine Georgia Waters as Eliza Millan Tesfazgi as Cami Tammy Gillis as Deputy Marissa Staub David Kaye as Jerry Hugo Ateo as Sarge Alvina August as Viv Graeme Duffy as Deputy Clarence Broadus Mattison as Fisherman Richard Thompson as Deputy Bethany Brown as Wanda Saskia Wedding as Kissing Partner #2 Derek Wallis as Cute Male Kissing #1 Morgana Wyllie as Customer #1 Myfanwy William as Mermaid Corpse Half Transformed