Guest Stars Maggie Lawson as Natalie Flynn Andrew Patrick Ralston as Jim McNeile Michelle Hurd as Gina Santos Peter Coventry Smith as Garrett Riggs Brandon Keener as Jeff Marlon Young as George Phoebe Dorin as Dog Owner Andre Eriksen as Zovra Umarov Co Starring Shay Rudolph as Maya George Wahba as Hanni Deborah Carson as Reporter Dale Waddington Horowitz as Judge Joshua Wolf Coleman as Doctor J. Doc Farrow as Uni #2 Jake O'Flaherty as Driver Marcelo Olivas as Wendell Josh Archer as EMT Dah-Uh Morrow as Uni Korbin Miles as Donnie Dennis Zen as Aide