Guest Stars Paul Campbell as Galen Eckhart Rob LaBelle as Cam Adams Megan Leitch as Ava Day Ryan Bruce as Corey Holman Co Starring Rebecca Davis as Molly Vance Courtney Richter as Ava Nicole Day / Pam Joyner Lee Tichon as Man in Scrubs #1 Tasha Simms as Florence Karissa Ketter as Young Ava (Ava) Will Verchere Gopaulsingh as Young Corey (Joey) Kurtis Maguire as Earl Christopher Logan as Doctor Jenny Norris as Joan Violet Cameron as Tiffany Blake Lily Killam as Young Sam (Melody) Paul Jarvie as Chucky Gilroy Tyson Bellusci as Man in Scrubs #2 Cesar Ventura as Russ Butler Bill Nikolai as Bernie Susie Lee as Screaming Woman Mizinga Mwinga as Jeff