Guest Stars David Call as Andy "Brick" Brickowski Jay O. Sanders as Chief Tom Lidell Ellen Adair as Bess McTeer Adam David Thompson as Adam Lowry Samrat Chakrabarti as Benji Shah Marceline Hugot as Sister Joanna Co Starring Michael Mann as Terry Maceo Oliver as Garrett Faye Yvette McQueen as D'Nell Aaron Roman Weiner as Deputy Sheriff Uly Schlesinger as Chester Dean Neistat as State Police #1 Natasha Strang as State Police Officer