Guest Stars David Froman as Lt. Bob Brooks Steven Anderson as D.A. David "Hangman" Hawkins Daniel Roebuck as Alex Winthrop Mike Pniewski as Father David Burke Michael Spound as Father Paul Richards Robert Miranda as Nathan Carlino Heidi Swedberg as Sister Katherine Leo Penn as Father Fitzgerald Fran Ryan as Doris Curtis Bert Hinchman as Mr. Bell Co Starring Nick DeMauro as Charlie Elizabeth Hoffman as Judge Mary Russell Michael C. Matthews as Street Kid #1 T.J. McGee as Street Kid #2