Guest Stars Gail O'Grady as Krystall Richards Lara Phillips as LeeAnne Garrity Co Starring Danielle C. Ryan as Portia Richards Janet Song as Lydia Garland Amanda Westlake as Ella Hicks Archer Moller as Young Unsub Olivia DiNino as Penny Cumbre Drew Cash as Scott Gillen Rosemary Alexander as Dorothy Elgin Seychelle Brown as Laura Burgess Gracie Lane as Delta Coughlan Mary Elizabeth Boylan as Cindy Underwood Niko Papastefanou as Unsub Khalif Boyd as Ben Hicks Mashari Bain as M.E. Theresa Caldwell Libby Baker as Mary Brewer Christopher Darga as Sheriff Wesley Hayes