Special Guest Stars David Hull as Josh "White Josh" Wilson Guest Stars Erick Lopez as Hector Michael McMillian as Tim Esther Povitsky as Maya Michael Hyatt as Dr. Akopian Michael Hitchcock as Bert Buttenweiser Olivia Edward as Madison Whitefeather David Grant Wright as Nathaniel Plimpton II Allison Dunbar as Stacy Whitefeather Patton Oswalt as J. Castleman Kathy Najimy as Herself Co Starring Siri Miller as Debra (Fabulous Girl) Michael Gabiano as Benjamin Martin Garcia as Gary Devin Sidell as Tara Paul Wong as Mr. Trapani Anthony Marciona as Christopher Karole Foreman as Susan Warren Lieberstein as Detective Angela Fornero as Jana Dan Levy as Fedora Guy Joshua Rodriguez as Home Base Patron Valerie Yu as Devon Lee Cloie Wyatt Taylor as Elise