Guest Stars Josh Stewart as Detective William LaMontagne Jr. Brighton Sharbino as Chelsea Davis Madeline Carroll as Ally Macready Dan Gauthier as Ethan Howard Breana Raquel as Bethany Wilson Co Starring Mekhai Andersen as Henry LaMontagne Phoenix Andersen as Michael LaMontagne Will Green as Brent DeDe Drake as Sandy Keana Marie as Riley Taylor Madeline Blake as Roslyn Jareau Rob Poynter as Tom Davis Cherish Hughes as Young Jennifer Bradley Upton as Jennifer's father Yuri Brown as Nurse