Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Laurie Holden as Greta Bellows David Alpay as Dylan Jennifer Parsons as Helen Scott Josh Clark as Jack Scott Harry Jarvis as Young Levi Liza Colón-Zayas as Lucia Rincon Co Starring Casey Tutton as Rosemary Lynch Ben Marten as Brian Husband Patrick Clear as Clarence Meyers Grace Fahey as Young Heather James Krag as Joe Welch Janet Ulrich Brooks as Judge Speer Karen Woditsch as Municipal Judge Will Zahrn as Judge - M&L Trial Adam Bitterman as Old Timer Firefighter Natalie McCann as Partygoer Mark L. Montgomery as Caleb Greeves Josh Hambrock as Bailiff - Speer Court Sylvia Perez as Local News Anchor Roosevelt Steart as Bailiff - Birkbeck Case Seb Torgus as Tobey Kissell Nancy Pender as Reporter HB Ward as Chief Firefighter Jesse Bob Harper as Thomas LeMay Lucy Carapetyan as EMT Alice Walker Ernest Perry Jr. as Harvey Birkbeck Joe Krowka as Frank Parker Dagoberto Zolio Soto as Deputy Sheriff - M&L Trial Dan Flannery as Judge - Birkbeck Case John Gawlik as Detective Ivan Vega as Damian Rincon