Guest Stars Zachary Levi as Benjamin Ettenberg Brandon Uranowitz as Buzz Goldberg Nolan Gerard Funk as Josh Saul Rubinek as Pauly Auerbach Co Starring Nunzio Pascale as Ethan Matteo Pascale as Ethan Matilda Szydagis as Zelda Jill Abramovitz as Stevie Barbara Mailey as Goldie Jacob Kemp as Samuel Laura Dreyfuss as Deecy Cheryl Stern as Ida Ariana Venturi as Alya Feinberg Christopher Manning as Kent Allison Strong as Talia Goldstein Barbara Miluski as Edie Arielle Goldman as Eliana Bridget Barkan as Steiner Resort Patron Singer David Vogel as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Carolyn Faye Kramer as Bernice Aram Peers as Striped Shirt Singer Alison Ingelstorm as Couple #4 Female Joe Ventricelli as Valet Singer Joseph Valle-Hoag as Kid Wrangler Singer Megan Mistretta as Striped Shirt Singer Grant Towers as Couple #6 Male Matt Caccamo as Bellhop Singer Camilla Zaepfel as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Jonny Cohen as Couple #4 Male Brett Parker Dixon as Bellhop Singer Adam Diloreto as Couple #5 Male Lily Ockwell as Couple #6 Female Evan Kasprzak as Couple #2 Male Jake Swain as Waiter Singer Jacob Pressley as Waiter Singer Daniel Wisniewski as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Jessica Cohen as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Alex Domini as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Susan Cohen Destefano as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Glen Raphael as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Jessica McHugh as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Scott Raneri as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Gorman John Ruggiero as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Joanne Lessner as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Dane Biren as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Kenneth Boys as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Judy Dodd as Steiner Resort Patron Singer J.T. Horenstein as Morty Andy Schneeflock as Michael Howard Pinhasik as Steiner Doctor Singer Lauren Blumfield as Gabi Colin Israel as Michael Nussbaum Keith Buterbaugh as Saul Barbara Walsh as Fur Lecturer Sigali Hamberger as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Vin Scialla as Steiner Chef Singer Jayson Wesley as Leonard Patricia M. Lawrence as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Reed Armstrong as Steiner Resort Patron Singer Leasen Almquist as Mr. Fuchtwanger's Dance Partner Drew King as Marnie's Dance Partner Trevor Braun as Feivish Michael Marotta as Mr. Fuchtwanger Betty Weinberger as Marnie Sarah Beymer as Joel's Dance Partner Nikki Croker as Dancer Jessica Treubig as Dancer Emily Palmquist as Saul's Dance Partner Jessica Swesey as Couple #1 Female Billy Cohen as Couple #1 Male Rachel Guest as Couple #2 Female Amy Yakima as Couple #2 Female Diana Brownstone as Couple #3 Female Steve Boockvor as Couple #3 Male Uncredited Rhett Kalman as Dancer