Guest Stars Todd Susman as Judge Mathias Cleary Frank Harts as ADA Madden Holly Taylor as Chloe Newhouse William Sadler as Father Andy Sean Patrick Reilly as Monsignor Espinoza Ty Doran as Jacob Kathleen Mary Carthy as Carol Co Starring Cameisha Cotton as Jessica Ozzie Stewart as Potential Juror #7 Byron Clohessy as Officer Avery Jenny L. Saldaña as Harried Mother Malcolm C. Murray as Officer Lambert Kasey Buckley as Officer Raney Gabby Cocco as Morgan Newhouse DC Williams as Eric James Lynch as Potential Juror #9