Guest Stars Lake Bell as Donna David Bloom as Kevin Michael Blaiklock as Danny Josh Charles as Blake Michaela Watkins as Rhonda Rich Sommer as Graham Eric Nenninger as Warner David Wain as Yaron Chris Pine as Eric Randall Park as Jeff Jordan Peele as Alan Paul Scheer as Dave Jayma Mays as Jessica Beth Dover as Shari Weird Al Yankovic as Jackie Brazen Co Starring Thomas Barbusca as Drew Isaak Presley as Kyle Samm Levine voices Voice of Arty George Dalton as Arty Alexandra Stamler as Debbie Josh Douglas as Rafi Hannah Friedman as Becky Dan Klein as Jeremy Hailey Sole as Amy E.J. Callahan as Elderly Clerk Gary Kraus as Glen Brenda Ballard as Lucille Maari Tommon as Customer