Special Guest Stars Bobby Cannavale as Angie "AJ" Geils Jr. Guest Stars John Michael Higgins as Randy Zaius Harry Hamlin as Leonard Scholls Romy Rosemont as Ellen Marmaduke Phil Morris as Samuel Hager Indira G. Wilson as Judge Sweeney Co Starring Katherine Skelton as Dorothy Blatt Melissa Denton as Co-Worker #2 Chiquita Fuller as Factory Worker Andrea Hutchman as Co-Worker #1 Adrian Bustamante as Raul Chamgerlain Gabriel Rodriguez as Mailman