Guest Stars Enuka Okuma as Suzanne Davis JJ Hawkins as Riley Hooper Conor O'Farrell as Gary Evans Enid Graham as Amanda Sharp Caroline Neff as Abby Nadji Jeter as Rashaad Co Starring Rammel Chan as Matthew Lee Maximus Chase Evans as Benny Young Guy Van Swearingen as Commander George Redding Lionel Segee Moise as Local Anchor #2 Amanda Dahl Powell as Natalie Vaughn Sandra Marquez as Principal Dougherty Paloma Nozicka as Michelle Ortega Samuel Joseph Dyer as Reporter #1 Anand Bhatt as Reporter #3 Nicole Michelle Haskins as Woman Nicholas Adam Freed as Alt-Right Thug Peter H. Moore as Father Joe Billick Dev Kennedy as Singing Cop #3 Haron Adoni Esho as National News Anchor Jennifer Grace as Another Reporter Hugh Callaly as Singing Cop #1 Katie Klein as Sergeant Lee Hoekstra Jim Gallanis as Singing Cop #4 John Lister as Singing Cop #2 Anita Chandwaney as Reporter #2 Lawrence Grimm as Bill Harrington Jonathan Keaton as Guy